I remember hearing about this idea waaay back in the day and I'm shocked it ever went to testing. Just doing the math on things would prove PC gamers would curb stomp consoles in the same game every time. The level of customization and freedom of hardware restrictions alone is enough to show that and then add into the ease of "modifying" the game (hacks, custom skins, custom reticles, macros, etc) and there shouldn't even be a contest.
sad how cheating is such a normal thing for pc kinda keeps me going back to xbox well and halo
PC's win against console players because a mouse and keyboard is far superior to joysticks in fps games, not because the PC players cheat or have expensive hardware.
Maybe if the consoles got some sort of handicap, like mega-auto aim. For non-fps games, like driving or sports im sure the match up would be much better.